In Israel, racism is the law
Al Jazeera
OPINION
In Israel, racism is the law
Successive Israeli governments since 1948 are responsible for the
institutionalised discrimination against Palestinians.
25 Feb 2016 .
Ben White is a freelance journalist, writer and activist, specialising in
Palestine/Israel.
On January 3, two Palestinians were removed from an Aegean Airlines flight
from Athens to Tel Aviv, after Jewish Israelis claimed that they constituted
a "security risk". The incident made headlines worldwide. A month later, a
Tel Aviv-based cleaning company sparked outrage with a flyer that priced its
staff based on ethnicity. The story was also covered around the world.
For some, these kinds of episodes are proof of the racism that critics claim
permeates Israeli society; for others, they are examples of isolated bigotry
and idiocy. In fact, neither interpretation is quite right. While stories
resonate and go viral, they can mask the fact that in Israel racism is the
law.
Institutionalised inequality
Netanyahu sets up committee to fight racism in Israel
First, inequality in Israel is institutionalised. Contrary to a widely held
perception, there is no guarantee of full equality for Jewish and
Palestinian citizens; as the Association for Civil Rights in Israel put it,
"the right to equality is not yet enshrined in law regarding most aspects of
life."
"Equality cannot be recognised on the constitutional level," wrote legal
academic Aeyal Gross, since that would challenge "the inequality created by
the complete identification of the state with only one group."
The nearest that Israel's foundational legislation comes to a specific
commitment to equality is Basic Law: Human Dignity and Liberty, adopted in
1992 - Israel does not have a formal, written constitution but a number of
"Basic Laws" passed over the years deal with key issues.
Yet even here, equality is not "recognised as an independent right that
stands on its own". In fact, just in the past month, the Knesset voted
against a draft bill that called for the inclusion of an equality clause in
Basic Law: Human Dignity and Liberty.
The Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, under military rule within
this de facto single state, are subjected to severe policies of
discrimination and segregation, as well as military brutality and
repression.
Furthermore, the Basic Law allows for rights to be violated "by a law
befitting the values of the State of Israel", a caveat that provides a basis
"for giving significant weight to the nature of Israel as a Jewish state and
its goals, at the expense of the fundamental rights concerned".
In the words of former Supreme Court President Aharon Barak: "Israel is
different from other countries. It is not only a democratic state, but also
a Jewish state." In other words, Israel is not a state of all its citizens,
something freely admitted by senior officials.
Second, Palestinian citizens of Israel face systematic discrimination in law
and policy - as these examples in land and housing, family life, and
immigration demonstrate.
In 43 percent of Israeli towns, residential admission committees filter out
applicants on the grounds of "incompatibility with the social and cultural
fabric". These committees, which operate by law, are "used to exclude Arabs
from living in rural Jewish communities", as Human Rights Watch has noted.
In 2014, the Supreme Court rejected a petition against the committees, a
ruling slammed for having legalised "the principle of segregation in
housing". These small communities also "exercise control over a significant
amount of land" through the regional councils of which they are part.
Palestinian citizens also face discrimination when it comes to family life.
The Citizenship and Entry into Israel Law, first adopted in 2003 (PDF),
"imposes severe restrictions on the right of Israeli citizens . to apply for
permits for their Palestinian spouses and children from the Occupied
Palestinian Territory to enter and reside in Israel for purposes of family
unification".
OPINION: Israel - This isn't how you defend democracy
This law, which has the effect of dividing Palestinian families and
separating spouses, has been described by a senior European Union official
as establishing "a discriminatory regime to the detriment of Palestinians in
the highly sensitive area of family rights".
Israel's Supreme Court upheld the law in 2012, stating (PDF): "human rights
are not a prescription for national suicide", putting its stamp of approval
- not for the first time - on a "racist law".
For the former Prime Minister, Ariel Sharon, the law was about
"demographics". "There is no need to hide behind security arguments," he
admitted. "There is a need for the existence of a Jewish state."
Perpetual status quo
While Palestinian citizens of Israel suffer under restrictions on family
unification, Jewish citizens benefit from Israel's discriminatory
immigration laws.
Israel's Law of Return, Absentee Property Law, and the Citizenship Law,
passed in 1948-1950, created a reality whereby any Jew in the world can move
to Israel and claim citizenship, while expelled Palestinian refugees were
stripped of citizenship and are still unable to return.
Israel's law "creates three tracks of naturalisation": the highest track for
Jews, a second track "for non-Jewish foreigners, who can apply for Israeli
residency status through a process of individualised interviews and
background checks", and the lowest track for "Palestinian/Arab/Muslim
spouses of Palestinian citizens of Israel who are prohibited from entry for
the purpose of family unification".
Third, 4.5 million Palestinians live under an Israeli military regime in the
West Bank and Gaza Strip, an occupation that has lasted for 49 of the
state's 68-year history. In other words, one in three of the population in
territory under Israel's control is not a citizen and is subject to
military, not civil, law.
It is important to remember that the territory occupied by Israel since 1967
is not, in practice, distinct from the rest of the state: land has been
expropriated, 600,000 Jewish Israelis live in more than 200 colonies,
natural resources are exploited, and basic infrastructure - water,
telecommunications, transport - all bind the West Bank to pre-1967
territory.
The Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, under military rule within
this de facto single state, are subjected to severe policies of
discrimination and segregation, as well as military brutality and
repression. This is no secret: as Human Rights Watch stated in 2010.
"Palestinians face systematic discrimination merely because of their race,
ethnicity, and national origin, depriving them of electricity, water,
schools, and access to roads, while nearby Jewish settlers enjoy all of
these state-provided benefits."
To enforce this "two-tier system", the Israeli military conducts nightly
raids, detains Palestinians without trial or charge, tortures detainees, and
represses any kind of resistance - including unarmed protests - with lethal
violence.
Who is responsible for all of the above - for the institutionalised
discrimination, the racist laws, and military rule over 4.5 million
Palestinians? Successive Israeli governments since 1948.
The crude racism of private individuals - whether on a Greek plane or at a
Tel Aviv cleaning company - might get the headlines, but it is the Israeli
state and its institutions that created and perpetuates the colonial status
quo, and which must be held to account.
Ben White is a freelance journalist, writer and activist, specialising in
Palestine/Israel.
The views expressed in this article are the author's own and do not
necessarily reflect Al Jazeera's editorial policy.
http://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/opinion/2016/02/israel-racism-law-160224111
623370.html?utm_source=Al+Jazeera+English+Newsletter+%7C+Weekly&utm_campaign
=3dfa961758-weekly_newsletter&utm_medium=email&utm_term=0_e427298a68-3dfa961
758-213748701
--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
"New Profile" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an
email to newprofile+unsubscribe@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx.
To post to this group, send email to newprofile@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx.
Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/group/newprofile.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout. I couldn't agree
more.
Dorothy
From: Jamal Najjab
Sent: Monday, February 29, 2016 8:01 AM
Subject: In Israel, racism is the law
Al Jazeera
OPINION
In Israel, racism is the law
Successive Israeli governments since 1948 are responsible for the
institutionalised discrimination against Palestinians.
25 Feb 2016 .
Ben White is a freelance journalist, writer and activist, specialising in
Palestine/Israel.
On January 3, two Palestinians were removed from an Aegean Airlines flight
from Athens to Tel Aviv, after Jewish Israelis claimed that they constituted
a "security risk". The incident made headlines worldwide. A month later, a
Tel Aviv-based cleaning company sparked outrage with a flyer that priced its
staff based on ethnicity. The story was also covered around the world.
For some, these kinds of episodes are proof of the racism that critics claim
permeates Israeli society; for others, they are examples of isolated bigotry
and idiocy. In fact, neither interpretation is quite right. While stories
resonate and go viral, they can mask the fact that in Israel racism is the
law.
Institutionalised inequality
Netanyahu sets up committee to fight racism in Israel
First, inequality in Israel is institutionalised. Contrary to a widely held
perception, there is no guarantee of full equality for Jewish and
Palestinian citizens; as the Association for Civil Rights in Israel put it,
"the right to equality is not yet enshrined in law regarding most aspects of
life."
"Equality cannot be recognised on the constitutional level," wrote legal
academic Aeyal Gross, since that would challenge "the inequality created by
the complete identification of the state with only one group."
The nearest that Israel's foundational legislation comes to a specific
commitment to equality is Basic Law: Human Dignity and Liberty, adopted in
1992 - Israel does not have a formal, written constitution but a number of
"Basic Laws" passed over the years deal with key issues.
Yet even here, equality is not "recognised as an independent right that
stands on its own". In fact, just in the past month, the Knesset voted
against a draft bill that called for the inclusion of an equality clause in
Basic Law: Human Dignity and Liberty.
The Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, under military rule within
this de facto single state, are subjected to severe policies of
discrimination and segregation, as well as military brutality and
repression.
Furthermore, the Basic Law allows for rights to be violated "by a law
befitting the values of the State of Israel", a caveat that provides a basis
"for giving significant weight to the nature of Israel as a Jewish state and
its goals, at the expense of the fundamental rights concerned".
In the words of former Supreme Court President Aharon Barak: "Israel is
different from other countries. It is not only a democratic state, but also
a Jewish state." In other words, Israel is not a state of all its citizens,
something freely admitted by senior officials.
Second, Palestinian citizens of Israel face systematic discrimination in law
and policy - as these examples in land and housing, family life, and
immigration demonstrate.
In 43 percent of Israeli towns, residential admission committees filter out
applicants on the grounds of "incompatibility with the social and cultural
fabric". These committees, which operate by law, are "used to exclude Arabs
from living in rural Jewish communities", as Human Rights Watch has noted.
In 2014, the Supreme Court rejected a petition against the committees, a
ruling slammed for having legalised "the principle of segregation in
housing". These small communities also "exercise control over a significant
amount of land" through the regional councils of which they are part.
Palestinian citizens also face discrimination when it comes to family life.
The Citizenship and Entry into Israel Law, first adopted in 2003 (PDF),
"imposes severe restrictions on the right of Israeli citizens . to apply for
permits for their Palestinian spouses and children from the Occupied
Palestinian Territory to enter and reside in Israel for purposes of family
unification".
OPINION: Israel - This isn't how you defend democracy
This law, which has the effect of dividing Palestinian families and
separating spouses, has been described by a senior European Union official
as establishing "a discriminatory regime to the detriment of Palestinians in
the highly sensitive area of family rights".
Israel's Supreme Court upheld the law in 2012, stating (PDF): "human rights
are not a prescription for national suicide", putting its stamp of approval
- not for the first time - on a "racist law".
For the former Prime Minister, Ariel Sharon, the law was about
"demographics". "There is no need to hide behind security arguments," he
admitted. "There is a need for the existence of a Jewish state."
Perpetual status quo
While Palestinian citizens of Israel suffer under restrictions on family
unification, Jewish citizens benefit from Israel's discriminatory
immigration laws.
Israel's Law of Return, Absentee Property Law, and the Citizenship Law,
passed in 1948-1950, created a reality whereby any Jew in the world can move
to Israel and claim citizenship, while expelled Palestinian refugees were
stripped of citizenship and are still unable to return.
Israel's law "creates three tracks of naturalisation": the highest track for
Jews, a second track "for non-Jewish foreigners, who can apply for Israeli
residency status through a process of individualised interviews and
background checks", and the lowest track for "Palestinian/Arab/Muslim
spouses of Palestinian citizens of Israel who are prohibited from entry for
the purpose of family unification".
Third, 4.5 million Palestinians live under an Israeli military regime in the
West Bank and Gaza Strip, an occupation that has lasted for 49 of the
state's 68-year history. In other words, one in three of the population in
territory under Israel's control is not a citizen and is subject to
military, not civil, law.
It is important to remember that the territory occupied by Israel since 1967
is not, in practice, distinct from the rest of the state: land has been
expropriated, 600,000 Jewish Israelis live in more than 200 colonies,
natural resources are exploited, and basic infrastructure - water,
telecommunications, transport - all bind the West Bank to pre-1967
territory.
The Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, under military rule within
this de facto single state, are subjected to severe policies of
discrimination and segregation, as well as military brutality and
repression. This is no secret: as Human Rights Watch stated in 2010.
"Palestinians face systematic discrimination merely because of their race,
ethnicity, and national origin, depriving them of electricity, water,
schools, and access to roads, while nearby Jewish settlers enjoy all of
these state-provided benefits."
To enforce this "two-tier system", the Israeli military conducts nightly
raids, detains Palestinians without trial or charge, tortures detainees, and
represses any kind of resistance - including unarmed protests - with lethal
violence.
Who is responsible for all of the above - for the institutionalised
discrimination, the racist laws, and military rule over 4.5 million
Palestinians? Successive Israeli governments since 1948.
The crude racism of private individuals - whether on a Greek plane or at a
Tel Aviv cleaning company - might get the headlines, but it is the Israeli
state and its institutions that created and perpetuates the colonial status
quo, and which must be held to account.
Ben White is a freelance journalist, writer and activist, specialising in
Palestine/Israel.
The views expressed in this article are the author's own and do not
necessarily reflect Al Jazeera's editorial policy.
http://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/opinion/2016/02/israel-racism-law-160224111
623370.html?utm_source=Al+Jazeera+English+Newsletter+%7C+Weekly&utm_campaign
=3dfa961758-weekly_newsletter&utm_medium=email&utm_term=0_e427298a68-3dfa961
758-213748701
