3 New Studies That Will Make You Rethink Systemic Racism
U.S. Department of Education / Flickr
Racism is like sewage. Whether we're currently engaging in a national
dialogue about it or not, it's still there. It runs under our streets, our
buildings, our society. Millions of tons of shit.
A few months ago, a national dialogue about race bubbled up to the surfice
in all its stinking, rancid glory. That dialogue flared up when we all found
out that the governor of my home state of Virginia, Ralph Northam, appeared
in his medical school yearbook photo wearing blackface beside someone in a
Klan hood (or perhaps it was him in the Klan hood next to a guy in
blackface-neither explanation really helps his case). And in that moment, we
could all see what racism looks like. It was tangible. It was real. We could
point to it and cringe.
That kind of racism is actually rare. More often, it trickles along beneath
our collective consciousness, quietly infecting everything.
Systemic racism is not as obvious, and a lot of people try to claim it no
longer exists. "It's gone. What systemic racism? 'Black Panther' was one of
the most popular movies ever, therefore, racism is over," they claim.
Unfortunately, it doesn't work like that.
Three recent studies prove just how many millions of gallons of fetid,
systemic racism still fill our country. Let's start with education. A couple
months ago, a new report found a $23 billion racial funding gap for schools.
The report stated:
"Overwhelmingly white school districts received $23 billion more than
predominantly non-white school districts in state and local funding in 2016,
despite serving roughly the same number of children."
Let me repeat that number so it echoes in your head: twenty-three billion
dollars! The following should go without saying, but I'm going to say it
anyway, because I'm kind of a dick that way: Education is important.
A kid's entire life can rest on the type of early schooling he or she
receives. A good education creates opportunities; a bad education shuts
doors in a child's future face. (I don't mean she has a face from the future
or even a futuristic face. I mean in the future, the door is shut in her
face. You probably knew that.)
In schools with the most funding, students are given laptop computers and
trained how to succeed. In the least funded schools, teachers dole out
antiquated textbooks that say dinosaurs were large frogs and slavery was
just an early American internship program that got out of hand.
This is when the squishy liberals say, "Lee, that's because we have a racist
president who hates funding the education of people of color." And while I
agree that having a racist president doesn't help matters, that $23 billion
is from 2016, while President Obama was still in office.
Squishy liberals then reply, "But that can't be. I thought Obama ended all
racial inequality and brought love and Tootsie Pops to the world."
No, not exactly. You're only two words off, though. Obama ended all
reporting on racial inequality. Fewer people mentioned the sewage under our
society when he held the highest office. You see the difference? The cold
truth is that systemic racism against black, Hispanic and indigenous people
exists no matter who's in the White House.
Let's move on to climate change. There can't possibly be racial disparity
when it comes to weather, could there? Hurricanes don't exactly hit only
black neighborhoods.
True. But racist policies often come into play after the storms or flood
waters have subsided.
A new NPR investigation "found that white communities nationwide have
disproportionately received more federal buyouts after a disaster than
communities of color."
One of FEMA's services for disaster-ravaged towns is to purchase damaged
properties when people don't want to live there anymore. And yet, according
to the NPR report:
"
Federal disaster aid is allocated based on a cost-benefit calculation meant
to minimize taxpayer risk. That means money is not necessarily doled out to
those who need it most but rather to those whose property is worth more -
and to those who own property in the first place.
This fact kind of blew me away. We have created a Federal Emergency
Management Agency designed to help the rich the most after a horrible
disaster. Just off the top of your head, who do you think needs the most
help after a natural disaster? I'll give you a hint-it's the poor.
This whole thing would be sort of funny if you read it in a satirical novel
about a dystopian future or something. But seeing as it's written by our
government, it's about as funny as flesh-eating bacteria.
In this particular instance, systemic racism does not originate in race but
instead in the way the rich have crafted our laws and our systems to favor
the rich. So it's a class issue, rather than a race issue. Unfortunately,
other factors of systemic racism-such as hiring practices, and who gets
promoted-ensure that white people are more likely to be extremely wealthy
and less likely to be extremely poor. Therefore, our country has a racial
wealth gap the size of the Grand Canyon (only that's a much less fun tour).
Workplace racism would require an entirely separate column, so I won't get
into it here, other than to point out you're 50% less likely to get the
first interview for a job if you have a black-sounding name.
Back to the wealth gap. According to a Duke University paper titled "What We
Get Wrong About Closing the Racial Wealth Gap":
"
Data from 2014 shows that black households hold less than 7 cents on the
dollar compared to white households. The white household living near the
poverty line typically has about $18,000, while black households in similar
economic straits typically have a median wealth near zero. This means many
black families have a negative net worth.
That gigantic wealth gap affects where people live, and that brings us to
our third study, which finds a racial gap between who creates air pollution
and who is forced to inhale it.
If you're like me, you're now thinking, "Oh come on! I know white people can
be dicks, but I've never seen an angry white guy with petrochemicals
shooting out his ass. What are these researchers talking about?"
Well, according to the report, they're saying:
"
While we tend to think of factories as the source of pollution, those
polluters wouldn't exist without consumer demand for the products. . Air
pollution is disproportionately caused by white Americans' consumption of
goods and services, but disproportionately inhaled by black and Hispanic
Americans.
Okay, I'll begrudgingly grant them that. But has anyone stopped to ask why
black and Hispanic Americans choose to breathe so much?! Slow it down. Skip
every other breath (just like people do when they're around Rush Limbaugh).
Have some will power!
This study shows that due to the wealth gap and population differences,
white people create the majority of the pollution in our country. Minorities
then end up breathing it in their air or drinking it in their water because
they more often live in corporate sacrifice zones-areas where the property
value is lower and corporations feel free to destroy the landscape. And
again, that comes back to the wealth gap.
(If I'm honest, as a white person, I'm not surprised that white people
create the most pollution by using and buying the most stuff. I have family
members who own polish for the shoe tree that holds the shoes their pet
rabbit wears. They own knitted cozies for remote controls that go to
cordless devices that do things they don't need done. They buy things to
take care of things that go on things that attach to nothing! And making
those meaningless things creates pollution, and then a nonwhite person has
to breathe in goddamn rabbit shoes. You know how many micro-particles of
bedazzled cellphone cases nonwhite people drank in their water last year?!
It's a fucked-up system, to say the least.)
All told, much of our systemic racism problem comes down to class and
wealth, not just race. But race, class and wealth are deeply, inexorably
linked. And therefore, whether you choose to ignore it or not, we must
acknowledge that systemic racism is a thing. It's in our schools, our air,
our water, and even our televisions. It impacts every area of our lives, and
much like climate change, we need to start fixing it, rather than acting
like it doesn't exist.
-
If you think this column is important, please share it. Also you can join
Lee Camp's free email newsletter here.
This column is based on a monologue Lee Camp wrote and performed on his TV
show "Redacted Tonight."
Lee Camp
