Hi Jill, You as the validator have the final say on book quality. And often times a book will be rated "good" when submitted, but once you have done some editing, the rating may very well go up to excellent. Pam >I have just validated my first book, but before trying to upload it I have a >couple of questions. This book was reported as good, but actually I found >hardly any errors. Who determines the rating and how? Since it wasn't my type >of book, I didn't read it entirely through but did a lot of sampling. I am >reading a book right now rated excellent and it is far from it; this is a book >that has already been validated. Thank you. Jill