Dear Volunteers, If the person who scanned Forty Signs of Rain by Kim Stanley Robinson is monitoring I'd like to ask if you scanned a paperback or hardbound copy of it. I've downloaded it and would like very much to validate it. Always With Love, Lissi ----- Original Message ----- From: Estelnalissi To: bksvol-discuss@xxxxxxxxxxxxx Sent: Thursday, January 26, 2006 4:09 PM Subject: [bksvol-discuss] William Wallace my 8th Dear Volunteers, E Haw! My 8th validated book appeared in the collection today. It is William Wallace, The King's Enemy by D J Gray! It is 161 pages of text and a well researched biography of Wallace which narrates his life in the context of Scottish history and in relation to Edward I of England. The history is fact filled and a quick read, rarely bogged down or dull. However, today I got a shock at the second hand bookstore. I found a much larger sized hard bound biography of Wallace called William Wallace, the Man Who Was Brave Heart. I couldn't see enough of the print to be certain, but it appears this is a more complete, and probably the original biography upon which the book I just validated was based. My book is a Barnes and Noble edition and it appears Barnes and Noble comissioned a shorter version. The book I found had about 110 additional pages of text and a longer index. Had I known, I'd never have bought the shortened version and requested that it be scanned. It's not all bad news. The biography I validated is excellent and probably more interesting to a reader who doesn't necessarily want to hear every detail of a battle or a more detailed account of Wallace's travels and activities. The shortened version is just that, shorter but not dumbed down. The author's words are in tact. There are just fewer of them. Below my signature are the short and long descriptions of the book. Always With Love, Lissi short concise, interestingly told, biography of William Wallace, Braveheart, whose selfless passion to free Scotland inspired his countrymen to defy King Edward I of England's tyranny. long Born in 1274, William Wallace, without land or title, began in his teens to raise the hopes of his fellow scotts that with intelligence, unity and bravery they could expel the armies of King Edward I which invaded Scotland taking its wealth, land and freedom. He triumphed in numerous battles, large and small, including the battle of Stirling. Though named the Guardian of Scotland by his devoted countrymen, he never accepted financial reward, land or power. Freedom was his only ideal. He was betrayed for ten shillings and bravely suffered a brutal death at the hands of the English king who feared and hated him. This is a scholarly and fascinating biography of Wallace, a brilliant warrior and admirable hero.