Pam, Whether one or the other of those units is better is probably a matter of some debate, as their feature sets vary a little, and the interface they present varies as well. You can't listen to either device without headphones or powered speakers. Theere is no built in speaker on either one. The Courier is a little cheaper. I don't know if there's a discount for BookShare members who want to purchase the BookPort as there is with the Courier. I have the Courier and have been satisfied with it, although its not without its quirks. Mary