[bksvol-discuss] What a synopsis shouldn't be
- From: "Bob" <rwiley@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- To: "bookshare volunteer discussion" <bksvol-discuss@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Thu, 25 Jun 2009 09:56:29 -0500
Here is a description of a book just placed in the collection.
"Sudden Death, by
David Rosenfelt
Brief Synopsis: - David Rosenfelt's previous novel. "Bury the Lead, was
published in Mysterious Press hardcover in 6/04, and was a "Today show Book
Club Pick chosen by
Janet Evanovich.
Long Synopsis: - David Rosenfelt's previous novel. "Bury the Lead, was
published in Mysterious Press hardcover in 6/04, and was a "Today show Book
Club Pick chosen by
Janet Evanovich.- "First Degree (Mysterious Press, 5/03) won raves from
national publications, including "Entertainment Weekly, and starred reviews from
both "Kirkus Reviews and "Publishers Weekly.- The author's debut novel. "Open
and Shut (Mysterious Press, 2002), was nominated for an Edgar Award for Best
First Novel and was praised in the "New York Times.- David Rosenfelt's previous
three books were Featured Alternates of The Mystery Guild," with foreign
rights sold in Bulgaria, France, Germany, and Japan."
There are no categories listed for this book, and it was submitted by bookshare
staff.
I'm sure Mr. Rosenfelt is a good writer--in fact these synopses verify that
fact. I further assume that he writes mysteries from the awards he has won.
But, in my opinion, these are exactly what a synopsis should not be. We learn
nothing about the book itself, and have no clue as to why we would want to read
it
Now, perhaps I'm just being grumpy, but this really gets to me. I know I could
download the book, read it and write a synopsis, or I could probably look on
Amazon.com or google books and find a summary I could put into my own words.
But, I don't feel it's right to do someone else's job for them.
Ok, rant over. Am I right to complain? or should I just ignore what I see as a
non synopsis?
Bob (probably needs more coffee)
"Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful,
committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is
the only thing that ever has."--Margaret Mead
Other related posts:
