Kellie I would like to see, in such instances, both the submitter and validator notified about the problem and what exactly looks suspicious about the questionable date of copyright? Else, validators are going on a goosechase with little likelihood of clearing things up to Gustavo's satisfaction. I'm to the point, particularly with scanning a book, that unless the word or copyright symbol appears on a title page, there are going to be problems. I understand what Gustavo's concern is, or at least I think I do, but I think that the communication needs to be etter on this explaining what looks suspicious or questionable. And this would presumably vary from case to case.