Alison, If it says submit, that's the original scanner who submitted it. Return means that it came back to the list, either because somebody's time ran out or they released it. Sometimes, it says edit time expired. If its actually been validated, you will see something like action valid and some numbers of some kind and then what sounds to me like donedone. And then if you see comments after that, they should be from the admin asking something or commentingon the reason why the book has been sent back after it has been deemed valid by a validator. But submit and return are the normal things under comments that indicate the original submission and the various edit sessions that didn't result in validation. You shouldn't see more than one submitter for a book, I don't think. Mary