I don't know, that sounds like another rule. Some see the galaxy complete with arms. Some see a tiny glow. If they're truly pointed at it and see it (or a supernova goes off while they're looking), you gotta give them credit. Jack Jones Saguaro Astronomy Club Public Events Lunar List Awards and Messier Marathon Co-coordinator Phoenix AZ spicastar@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx > > >> ...but why is the light of > > >> other stars a legal observation, but light from this particular star > > >> a bogus observation? > > >Brian Skiff <Brian.Skiff@xxxxxxxxxx> replied: > > At least for the purposes of a Messier Marathon-type observation, > >I would argue that the supernova wouldn't count because it isn't what > >Messier himself saw as M74. > > > >\Brian > >-- > > Excellent point! -- See message header for info on list archives or unsubscribing, and please send personal replies to the author, not the list.