[acc_tr_vsk] Re: Replay - Micro challenge -

  • From: John Chambers <john.ch@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
  • To: acc_tr_vsk@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
  • Date: Thu, 13 May 2010 16:39:53 +0000 (GMT)

Marco in my opinion Quimiac is wrong he tried to luff and give you a pen but it 
was in the 2 boat circle so he gets a pen,but even when you are the inside boat 
it is not right to turn into the outside boat which you did not :)  then i 
think you were lucky with Gibo as you should have kept clear as windward boat i 
think he pushed you over the line just before you would have got a pen. This is 
the Nadeo rules which are wrong! as we all know you cannot claim room at a 
start...the same applies at a finish in real sailing but we will have to play 
the Nadeo version or it will all get very confusing.

Cheers, John.

--- On Thu, 13/5/10, Piaggio, Marco <marco.piaggio@xxxxxx> wrote:

From: Piaggio, Marco <marco.piaggio@xxxxxx>
Subject: [acc_tr_vsk] Replay - Micro challenge -
To: "acc_tr_vsk@xxxxxxxxxxxxx" <acc_tr_vsk@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Date: Thursday, 13 May, 2010, 9:57

Dear friends      
I send you a replay of  micro challenge race (same where jiel disconn).
2 questions please:
1)         at the finish line I slow quiniac without cross the line and give 
him a pen: is this correct?
2)         next I crash with GIBO very close to line: I think I had to give him 
room (no time to pen here; Gibo asks a pen but we cross the line). 
The score was
1                    Coli
2                    Gibo
3                    Darren
4                    Quiniau
Quiniac sayd he gave me room to finish, and the pen was not correct.
Gibo nothing said.
Thanks Merci Grazie.

Other related posts: