Mind control Joe Dever? Would help to solve some problems in the books, but unlikely to happen, I guess. At least next month we should finally know what Shamath's riddle was supposed to be for the first time EVAH! :-D
That's got to go straight in the PA edition. With some kind of re-release. No more Shamath's riddle questions, queries, and threads on the forum. Reason enough to get the outstanding errata sorted, no? ;-)
If it would help, for next week's Sprint, I could deviate from the norm and just pick 12-15 issues from all those remaining that I think are either almost certain to be Rejected, or are very straightforward to fix. That way, a cursory glance leads to proposals being sorted without any real work needing to be put in!
-- Simon Osborne Project Aon On 17/06/2011 11:39, David Davis wrote:
I guess that's "tidier", although I suspect the gentle reader is more likely to feel in need of a footnote when they encounter the ad-hoc bonus at the section in question. (If indeed they were ad hoc bonuses - it's things like this which are virtually impossible to answer conclusively without subjecting Joe Dever to the mind probe...) -- http://www.feline1.co.uk *On Fri 17/06/11 11:21 AM , Simon Osborne outspaced@xxxxxxxxxxxx sent: * On 17/06/2011 07:53, David Davis wrote: > PS however readers might still rightly think "oh, but the rules say +3 - > was that a mistake?" - > so I think each one should have a footnote "Note that that the Grand > Weaponmastery bonus for this particular piece of archery is higher than > the one stated in the Game Rules" ? Personally, I prefer the current (under-discussion!) model of footnoting Disciplines/Grand Weaponmastery to say that on occasion the bonus is more than +3. This meshes with your notes that the +4s and +5s are ad-hoc bonuses that Joe threw in for variety. We did something similar respecting the Sommerswerd and its potential enhanced CS bonus on the Plane of Darkness in Book 20--rather than footnoting each fight, we footnoted the Game Rules. -- Simon Osborne Project Aon
~~~~~~ Manage your subscription at //www.freelists.org/list/projectaon
