On Tue, 2011-06-14 at 21:14 +0100, David Davis wrote: > I don't think there's any doubt that, if you've completed Books 1-12, and > choose Grand Weaponmastery, > you get +5 on the RNT with your Bow as a hidden loyalty bonus. > > And if the Grand Master books consistently said you get +3 RNT on your Bow, > both in their Game Rules and all sections, > I wouldn't bat an eyelid - it would be less powerful that Weaponmastery, but > that would be the same as for Deliverance vs. Curing. > > The only thing that makes me doubt is that in a few numbered sections of > Books 13, 14 and 15, > the Grand Weaponmastery bonus is given as +5 or +4, making it look like the > +3 in the Game Rules is a cut-and-paste error. > However Joe seems to have settled back to consistently having it as +3 in > later Grand Master books. perhaps the game rules should read "AT LEAST +3"? > > So, I think there's two ways to treat those rogue numbered sections: > 1. Leave them as is, on the basis that they're one-off explicit ad hoc > different bonuses for those specific combats. do the "rogue" +4/+5 bonuses mean that the player completely avoids a particular option? eg Pick a number from the Random Number Table. If you have Grand Weaponmastery (with Bow), add 4 to the number you have picked. If your total score is 0-3, turn to "section with auto-death" If it is 4-6, turn to "section where you take damage" If it is 7 or higher, turn to "you shoot the monster through the eye killing it, take no damage section" a +3 wouldnt necessarily mean you dont reach auto-death > 2. Correct them to +3, on the basis that Joe Dever got confuse. 3. leave as is and make a footnote saying "the bonus is usually +3, make your own mind up". perhaps in that particular case its an easy shot if youre a grand weaponmaster with a bow and so you get a higher than normal bonus (a bonus on your bonus). ~~~~~~ Manage your subscription at //www.freelists.org/list/projectaon