[projectaon] Re: Outstanding Errata Sprint (Week 2)

On 20/04/2011 18:58, Jonathan Blake wrote:

On Wed, Apr 20, 2011 at 1:44 AM, David Davis<feline1@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>  wrote:

For all our interesting discussions re the breakablity of the Dagger of
Vashna, none of which I disagree with the spirit of,
the legal pedant in me is at pains to stress that the 'Tekaro Sewer Defence'
from LW Newsletter 6 is the only canonical bit of rules advice we have on
the subject :) and as such I feel it has to form the basis of any footnote,
even if it's not entirely the answer we're wanting.
(And let's face it, compared the the Sommerswerd, the Dagger of Vashna is
next to useless, and if the Sommerswerd, personal gift of the God Kai,
forged on the Plane of Light, imbued with vast magical powers, and the
keystone of Ishir&  Kai's strategy for the salvation of all Aon, can
categorically as stated by Joe Dever get dissolved by a mere tentacle... ;)


I agree, so I would change "it seems reasonable to assume that you
would lose the Dagger of Vashna here" to "you should lose the Dagger
of Vashna here". I think that strengthens the case for requiring
discarding the DoV while maintaining the alternative at the discretion
of the reader. This fits the level of evidence for each case better,
IMHO.


OK, addressed this nit. Updated xml and /test/ area versions.
Who would have thought the earlier books would still contain so many in-depth problems? We've only had them complete for 8 years or so...! >_< 

--
Simon Osborne
Project Aon

~~~~~~
Manage your subscription at http://www.freelists.org/list/projectaon

Other related posts: