Thanks to all who participated in this conversation. From it's wrong, to why it's wrong, to why it existed and everything else discussed, this was interesting, civil and enlightening! You all make for a great forum. Cheers, Wayne In simple cases, presenting one obvious right way versus one obvious wrong way, it is often wiser to choose the wrong way so as to expedite subsequent revision. Fyfe's First Law of Revision - Corollary I -- //www.freelists.org/webpage/oracle-l