Hi Stephane, Thanks for answer ... wraping regular commands is not an options from the reasons you also mentioned. I played a little with the profile attributes and at least to my knowledge, this what I would like to get in the current version of 'oracle restart' is not possible ... maybe in next releases ... ;-) regards, goran On Mon, Dec 27, 2010 at 12:27 PM, Stephane Faroult <sfaroult@xxxxxxxxxxxx>wrote: > Goran, > > I suspect that to decide whether a resource was shut down intentionally > or not "oracle restart" checks for the presence of files that are normally > removed during a "clean" shutdown - typically files that contain a pid, or > something as classic as this. Therefore I doubt you can set any attribute. > What you can possibly do is wrap the regular commands (lsnrctl) into > scripts or your own that save files that are normally present only when the > resource is up (or crashed) to some location of your own, and have something > that restores (possibly selectively) those files when you want to restart > everything, whatever happened. But it looks to me rather complicated, not > necessarily easy to maintain if something changes in future versions, and > all things considered I'd rather script a restart of my own ... > > > HTH > > Stephane Faroult > RoughSea Ltd <http://www.roughsea.com> > Konagora <http://www.konagora.com> > RoughSea Channel on Youtube <http://www.youtube.com/user/roughsealtd> > > On 12/27/2010 11:50 AM, goran bogdanovic wrote: > > Hi, > > I recently checked this new oracle feature and come to a conclusions that > 'oracle restart' doesn't restart automatically resources (e.g. listener) if > being stopped manually using regular tools (e.g. lsnrctl). > In docs I have also found that this is intended behaviour of 'oracle > restart' > <> > Oracle utilities such as SQL*Plus, the Listener Control utility (LSNRCTL), > and ASMCMD are integrated with Oracle Restart. If you shut down the > database with SQL*Plus, Oracle Restart does not interpret this as a database > failure and does not attempt to restart the database. Similarly, if you shut > down the Oracle ASM instance with SQL*Plus or ASMCMD, Oracle Restart does > not attempt to restart it. > <> > > Does anyone knows is there any way to change this behaviour for specific > resource (like setting attribute) ... i.e. even if resource has been stopped > manually (not using srvctl or crsctl) 'oracle restart' will attempt to > restart it. > > many thanks, > goran > >