I think this is a very attractive toy. It will compete well with streaming services such as AppleTV and Netflix. Cable/DBS VOD guide is much less attractive then AppleTV guide. However, the Cable/DBS price is a larger issue. Why do I need Cable/DBS for VOD in the first place? Why I need Cable/DBS at all? Mike Tsinberg http://www.keydigital.com/ -----Original Message----- From: John McClenny [mailto:jamcclenny@xxxxxxxxx] Sent: Tuesday, May 18, 2010 11:58 AM To: opendtv@xxxxxxxxxxxxx Subject: [opendtv] Re: iPad remote for Comcast On Fri, May 14, 2010 at 3:51 PM, Manfredi, Albert E <albert.e.manfredi@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote: Craig Birkmaier posted: > An interesting demo of an iPad app to control Comcast cable boxes... > http://www.tvweek.com/blogs/tvbizwire/2010/05/videos-brian-roberts-demos-com.php This is one of those philosophically baffling applications. An application that ought to be included somewhere else, not in a hyper-expensive "remote control" that amounts to a TV set in its own right. The Internet TVs coming on line these days should, by all rights, incorporate everyhting the iPad does in this TV remote role. And instead of having to touch the screen with your own fingers, you just click a remote to push the "buttons" on the TV screen. Perhaps an IR-connected keyboard would also be available. Bert Bert, I think you will be seeing this from all the MSO/Telco/DBS providers. It provides a keyboard and better search platform without trying to shoehorn additional funtionality and cost into the STB. The traditional program guide is failing as the number of channels increases and the remote control sucks in entering search data. You can also bundle in a lot lot more funtionality that remote control emulation - a TvAnywhere type client and better integration between cable and OTT content. Will anyone buy an iPad to do this? Probably not, but if they already have an iPad, it is a nice incremental at zero cost. From the MSO side, it is a pretty cheap app to develop as long as you have some network interface to allow remote control of a STB - IT blasters don't make sense here. It doesn't require a new STB or remote control with keyboard and shifts the cost to the sub. For the MSO, this is a very low cost feature that pays for itself in buzz. Doc