Doragoy moy Valodsya Mihailovitch obviously intended this for the List
-------- Original Message --------Subject: Re: "the space of reasons" from Morc Huck Pump
Date: Mon, 17 Mar 2008 15:43:23 -0230 From: wokshevs@xxxxxxSome replies to Eric Y (und Herr Doktor Professor Seuss?)----------------->
Quoting Eric Yost <mr.eric.yost@xxxxxxxxx>:
WO: When I use the expression ["the space of reasons"], I refer to the epistemic justification of a proposition on the basis of reasons. Does that provide something of a background for my question?In "the space of reasons," the metaphor "space" when applied to the metaphoric term "reasons" suggests a form of discourse where someone's knowledge of a proposition is justified by a list of reasons. Or do I misconstrue?
--------> You misconstrue not. One cannot "know that" something is the case without being able to provide epistemically relevant justification for the knowledge-claim. (Btw, how is "reasons" a metaphoric term? Reasons are always
literal kinds of creatures, I would have thought.)
The proposition, "I do not like thee Doctor Fell / Although why I cannot tell " would therefore (by self-confession) fall outside the "space of reasons."
----------> It's like liking (or not) green eggs and ham. An expression of affinity for or against someone is not a knowledge-claim. So, yes, I would say that the expression falls outside the space of reasons.
In falling outside the space of reasons, the couplet is hurled headlong flaming from the ethereal sky / With hideous ruin and combustion down / To bottomless perdition, there to dwell / In adamantine chains and penal fire. Or something equally discrediting and uncomfortable for both proposition and proposer. Exile to some nasty anti-Quine universe where all a-posteriori knowledge can be proven true, maybe?
-----> Darn if I know! I can't discern any propositional content in any of the above sentences. (Which reminds me: a student in one of my undergrad classes asked me after class: "Walter, do you talk like that all the time?")
This generated by my notion that in art, the irrational can be held in a superbly rational container,
------------> Although Russian by birth, I have abjured that dimension of my soul long before attaining formal-operational cognitive capacities. After all, how long can one live a contradiction? (I just know I'm going to regret asking
Eric that question!) Cribbing from Notes From the Top of the Floorboards, Valodsya Mihailovitch Okshevsky
Eric
------------------------------------------------------------------ To change your Lit-Ideas settings (subscribe/unsub, vacation on/off, digest on/off), visit www.andreas.com/faq-lit-ideas.html