Paul D
Phil,
O'deary....i can live with a YES..to everything up to this point.....
From here I want you to relook at this demonstration from the beginning and alter
the rate of rotation of the top to spin at 100 rpm, and keep the orbits at 100 orbits per minute. They are synchronised. This is the only change we make. Will the ball now present the same face to the centre of the orbit? Difficult for anyone to visualise?. then try it with the spin of the shaft just One rpm and the orbit just one orbit per minute.
Of course the answer is yes. And we have two separate motions." NO!......You not going to like this at all and it is sure to keep your (not mine) debate going until either someone intellectually honest from the MS side of the aisle explains it to you, or you start to consider the forces involed........but the short of it is Phil, the only way to get your 100 RPM between your orbit and your spin to “synchronize”…is to continue to reduce the force applied to the spin of the ball until such time as there is a net zero spin force and a net zero spin rate wrt the parent body and the satellite….Phil, I’m sorry but this is fact that is can demonstrated even using your own basic apparatus for your own experiment, no matter what RPM and orbital rate you use....(note there must be some "engine" in both the orbit and the spin of your apparatus to cause thoes motions i will reference that force since the nature of forces are what you are
not understanding..) I will attempt to show this to you without going into all the techno jargon….but first I want the “shock” of what I just said to wear off so you will be able to think with a clear mind…..…so…go ahead and get it out all of your system , ..let it all out……I know the things I just said are outrageous to your scientific mind!…..
If you can pull yourself from the shock of my outrageous statements, and hold back your fury long enough to tell us,…. no trick question, I will give you my answer first……think about it….Is it possible to have two identical motors (Forces)under identical environmental conditions to produce the same effects with different energy inputs/outputs and rotation rates of the two motors…?
I would of course say no and expect anyone one else to say the same since if the RPMs or energy inputs are not the same then either the environmental conditions or the effects and or both are not the same…thus I would say if the effects are the same for two identical motors then the conditions are the same as well…..what say you?
If you disagree please tell us how we can have two identical motors under identical conditions have two different effects …
If you agree then for the two identical motors to have the same effects they must be in under identical conditions……. From: Allen Daves <allendaves@xxxxxxxxx> |