I know yours below is another advertising blitz for mammon, but I must defend against your assertions here. Robert posted. excerpt. #1. I would question the post by Robert Sungenis. (philip) Puzzling - if GWW is being ignored, then why read the excerpt from the book posted here? Interesting that the two that challenge GWW content here are also the two that haven’t read it. Is ignorance bliss? Exerpts from many books are posted here. And sometimes I or others challenge those statements. If a statement or argument cannot stand alone, but is put to obtain a sale, resisting answering the challenge, forgive me for questioning your motives. Why then did you put the post, if what I discern is not self evident? Yes, Philip, Bob and I wrote this over-priced book intending to become filthy rich by scamming the poor public with information that everyone knows and is readily available. But we couldn’t pull off that trick under your watchful eyes. Imagine our nerve – trying to recover the cost of publishing… As stated here before, one motivation for publishing was to avoid endless repetition of the same themes in different venues. But some people - 2 - want the pages of GWW to gradually be transferred into this forum in their quixotic belief that they have the right to any intellectual property on demand, without effort. Dream on. As you sow, brothers, you shall reap. If Bob and I were not members of this forum, I wonder if selling books would be an issue at all. Neville put no promotion restrictions on me, when I asked to promote the link to our website in one posting. You have presented some irrelevant results of bottom-fishing on the Net that disparaged Hildegard as a source, when you have no idea what chap 11 in GWW contains. Shooting from the hip with the lip is no problem? I find it rather childish that you would refer to me or anyone else as being ignorant, simply because we have ignored all the sales promos, and have not bought and read the great GWW. Is it as essential as the Bible.. But the Bible is free for all to read. I asked if ignorance was bliss. You haven’t answered but drew your own unintended inference. The Bible is free…. from the Gideon Society or the library. But some folks want to have their own personal Bible at home…. No accounting for taste, I guess. Btw: Are there no FREE public libraries down under ? Why not wait until GWW is available at penny sales at used book stores? :-) Or pass up the brews for a day or two and have enough cash for a book or two? :-):-) As for the rest here, You will have already gotten many posts sent since wherein I have re-evaluated my opinions and have already updated my reaction to Dr. Aspden.. And without it costing me a penny.. So there is no point in adding any more. I see your point. With unlimited time to surf, you can eventually recover GWW content from the Net. Some people don’t have that luxury; they need a shortcut. That’s why I separate sources for you and Paul from the rest. cheers, Philip. Pax Christi, brother. Robert