[gameprogrammer] Re: is Solitaire patented?

Hi!

Just one interesting link:

http://www.illnation.com/blog/2004/02/patent-nonsense.jsp

And if you want other proof why this patent system is far from perfect, just read the notes on LZW (or it was LZ77), somewhere I read, the patent office accorded three times the patent, because they failed to observe that they already had patents on it.

Szasz Pal wrote: 
Kevin Jenkins wrote:

There is a patent on playing solitaire on the computer.
http://www.chillingeffects.org/patent/notice.cgi?NoticeID=1070


Thats a very strange patent. as I undestood, it's about playing card games over the internet. But it's very strange, honestly I don't really believe there is no prior-art for this. The patent description seems too general. I don't think there wasn't any over-the-network played card games prior 1998 (when the patent was filled).
... or I am just misunderstanding something??? ..
About this claims, each claim bust the true for the patend together, or it's enough if one of them is true? As I see they start with soemthing general, and the following claims are specializations of the previous ones. So I suppose actually the last claim is the key one?

Grr.... I hate patents ... (and I'm glad I live in Europe ;-) )

Anyway, thanks for the link, I think I will dig a bit more in the patent topic ... so I might go mad in the following days :-)



--
Best regards,
Szasz Pal
----------------
Space Software Studio
http://www.spacesoftwarestudio.com


---------------------
To unsubscribe go to http://gameprogrammer.com/mailinglist.html


Other related posts: