[bct] Re: Holistic health-- auras - western medicine.

  • From: Slythy_Tove <mcg907@xxxxxxxxx>
  • To: blindcooltech@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
  • Date: Sun, 12 Feb 2006 16:43:55 -0800 (PST)

Actually, Jeff, I called it a rambling diatribe, and it was rambling from my 
point of view because I have to be very organized in my writing.  

Point by point answers follow, wandering along the path you took.

A lot of Christians do believe that hypnosis can let the devil enter your body, 
so what you got was a dose of religion, not chiropractic.  I believe some 
Muslims believe the same thing - not sure about that. 

I can quote cure unquote people of asthma by getting them off grains - if, in 
fact, they have a grain allergy causing asthma.  If they are not allergic to 
grains, then there is no help I have for them.  There are remedies for a lot of 
things, but someone who promises a cure is either deluded or falsely 
advertising things - or a miracle worker of some sort. 

Yet we have doctors promising vast weight losses from surgery and I had an MD 
promise me that if I saw him every three months forever that I would never lose 
the vision in my good eye - and I consider that to be a spurious claim on his 
part.  So it goes on all over -  listen to the claims on TV sometimes - the 
lawyer who will win you millions, the car that will make you young and popular, 
etc.  It is usually called "puffing" and considered a part of marketing.  

Intriguingly, I found your email regarding Dan's podcast insulting from the get 
go but chose not to respond in kind.  Nor did he.  In fact, I did not attack 
you, I merely observed your post was rambling and sounded like science 
fundamentalism, which I'm pretty used to hearing.  It used to pain me to no end 
that Carl Sagan was a science fundamentalist because he could not see the 
dicotomy in his description of the cosmos that he could not confirm in person 
and his belief that he had to quanitify the unquantifiable. 

As regards your aunt, you sounded angry.  In social work I met a lot of angry 
people and I tend to recognize anger and sarcasm when I experience it.  I am a 
wordsmith - a writer, a researcher, a student of human behavior and expression. 
 Frankly, you sounded angry.  

Also, I have never claimed to see an aura, in fact, I have disclaimed being 
able to see auras.  You confuse me with Dan.  I'm not Dan.  

Legally, there is no requirement for someone to save someone else.  Surprised?  
I sure was.  If you see someone drowning you do not have to attempt to save 
them.  The chiro was not legally obligated to refer.  Morally, yes, I would 
agree to that.  

I've never met a chiro who thought he could do anything.  You must have met 
some real doozies.  

As to death being natural - children die at birth, they die as little kids, 
they die of cancer and cystic fibrosis and all sorts of things.  People die as 
adults, as young adults and as elderly adults.  Death, even death from cancer, 
even death from cancer at 53 is not an unnatural thing.  It is sad.  We do not 
know if it was needless or not, since my experience with life and death is 
different from yours.  I felt my mother's death from cancer at age 62 was one 
of the most profound tragedies in my life at the time, but I have also come to 
understand that it was also one of the most profound learning and growth 
experiences in my life.  I believe that we come to this world and live in this 
world and leave this world with intention.

I actually wasn't ranting.  Sorry you feel that way.  

As to photography, are you aware that without photography that there would be 
no microchip in the computer you use and that is demonstration of the 
scientific use of photography in action?  Are the photographs from the Hubble 
non-scientific?  The photographs from electron microscopes?  And, to be honest, 
at the pixel level I can always spot a photo that has been altered.  I do 
graphics.  I can manipulate images.  You can detect it pretty easily if you 
simply have the tools to look. Just as voice prints can be manipulated and one 
can detect that manipulation with the right level of sophisticated tools.

As to electrical energy in the body - it is electrical energy that makes your 
heart beat.  Our neurons in our body use chemical energy which is a form of 
electrical activity.  

Actually, doctors not being god has nothing to do with religion, it has to do 
with people acting as if doctors are god.  They are not. 

You are wrong, people do still rub two sticks together to start a fire all over 
the world - including boy scouts and girl scouts.  Oops.  And it is merely 
another method of creating fire - it is not primitive - it is different.  

If we only used useful things we would not do much of what we do even in so 
called modern medicine.  We would not have lobotomized people.  We would not 
continue to force children to take antipsychotics just to calm them down when 
they are not psychotic.  We would not administer antipsychotics to elderly 
persons in nursing homes to make them easier to control - even though they are 
not psychotic.  That is useful, certainly, but also morally reprehensible.  As 
bad as driving devils out of little children and killing them in the process or 
doing rebonding with small children and killing them.  

If genetic blindness is such a problem, why does it still exist?  Wouldn't all 
those genes have been bred out of the population through death of the weak 
link?  I'm sorry, the argument you made fails.  

As to my providing you scientific proof of an aura, I don't see that is my 
responsibility or that of Dan.  That is silly - I could equally demand that you 
prove it does not exist, which you cannot do.   In all honesty, I don't have 
the time to do your research for you so I guess you will have to dig it up on 
your own - or not, as you chose.  You are certainly free to participate in the 
skeptic.com mentality of attempting to quote debunk unquote something by saying 
it isn't so, but it appears to me that you are talking from a point of lack of 
knowledge and daring others to provide you with something you would never 
accept if it fell in your lap.  That's really rather sad as I consider the 
impossible all the time - and often find it is possible.  

We still disagree - and I suspect we will continue to disagree. 

Slithy - back to researching - but not auras

Other related posts: