One instance of a particular word is enough to trigger the algorithm to give a book an adult rating? I believe that is extremely unreasonable. I would be interested to know who decided on such a draconian filtering system.
It may be true that a staff member can override the decision of the algorithm, but how often does that happen? Certainly proofreaders can override it as well, but you are still letting the algorithm trump the human judgment of submitters.
Then there are all those publisher donated books. Is a staff member going to check on each one of those to determine whether the judgment of the algorithm is valid or not? It seems unlikely that a staff member would have the time for that, especially in the light of the thousands of PQ books that are projected to be coming along in the near future. If all those books are not going to be checked by a human, then you are de facto letting an algorithm trump human judgment, since the ability to override it is of no meaning if it isn't being used.
Evan----- Original Message ----- From: "Nicole Gnutzman" <nicoleg@xxxxxxxxxxxx>
To: <bksvol-discuss@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>Cc: "Scott Rains" <scottr@xxxxxxxxxxxx>; "Julie Carpenter" <juliec@xxxxxxxxxxxx>
Sent: Tuesday, May 11, 2010 2:43 PM Subject: [bksvol-discuss] adult content designation
Dear volunteers,I'm the Director of Literacy Operations at Benetech (you can go to http://www.benetech.org/about/management_team.shtml#ng to check out my profile). The Volunteer Program, Collections Development, Membership and Technical Support groups report to me. You may see me chime in periodically on policy-related issues raised by the volunteer list when the policy is outside of the volunteer program, but still under the purview of operations. I'll leave volunteer policy communication in the capable hands of Scott and Pavi. All policy-related communication is reviewed by me; Betsy Beaumon, General Manager, Literacy Program; and Jim Fruchterman, Benetech's CEO.Scott and Julie Carpenter, Collections Development Manager, brought the adult content designation issue to my attention and we sought input from the team at Benetech to answer your questions and concerns.The adult content designation has been in place at Bookshare from its launch in 2002. From the start of the membership process, minors are protected from viewing adult content. The default for all members under the age of 18, including students covered by the Bookshare for Education grant, is to NOT see adult content. A parent or guardian must give permission to Bookshare in writing for members under the age of 18 to access books with adult content. Although the default for members over 18 is to have all content enabled in Bookshare, all members over the age of 18 may choose to block adult content. This feature is in "My Account" under "Preferences."Bookshare has developed an adult content filter that runs all text through a quality assurance (QA) process in which the text is compared to two lists of trigger words. One list is of terms severe enough that one instance of that word trips the adult content filter; the other list requires multiple instances of the term to trip the filter. No matter whether the filter is tripped or not, the final determination is still made by a member of the collection development team. We do not allow an algorithm to trump human judgment when it comes to placing books in the adult content category.Bookshare is content-neutral and strives to serve all portions of its community. This includes members in our community who wish to opt-in to seeing adult content and those who wish to opt-out of seeing this material. We are grateful for all volunteer contributions to our collection.Best, Nicole Nicole Gnutzman Director, Literacy Operations nicoleg@xxxxxxxxxxxx www.bookshare.org www.benetech.org
To unsubscribe from this list send a blank Email to bksvol-discuss-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx put the word 'unsubscribe' by itself in the subject line. To get a list of available commands, put the word 'help' by itself in the subject line.
