Let me make something clear. I did not urge Kim to spend money on wish list books just to make people happy per se. It was simply that she mentioned making people happy as a strong reason for buying books and sending them to Bookshare and I suggested that if she was going to spend the money anyway she could be better assured that it would make someone happy if she selected books from the wish list to buy. It occurred to me that she might not have thought of that. As for myself, I don't have much money to spend on books, but even so, I have bought some for Bookshare myself. In my case, though, given that limited budget, I have bought some books to scan myself and if I am going to put all the effort into them that scanning entails my prime criteria for selecting them is to make me happy. I have put a number of titles on the wish list that are a bit too expensive for me and are not available in my local library, but I have no intention of asking anyone else to spend money on them for me. I simply figure that if they are on the wish list they might stand a better chance to make it into the collection by whatever means than if they are not there. One of them, in fact, I have my eye on as a possible scan for myself. I just might fulfill one of my own wishes. If, on the other hand, my motivation was to just make other people happy by either spending my money or time on books I do think I would look more closely at the wish list for making a selection. Even so, though, I would, of course, look for books on the wish list that I was interested in too and give those priority. I think any of us would do that. Whatever the case, though, I just wanted to make it clear to anyone who might have misunderstood that I am not trying to tell anyone how to spend their money. "I have no country to fight for; my country is the earth, and I am a citizen of the world." Eugene V. Debs The Militant: http://www.themilitant.com Pathfinder Press: http://www.pathfinderpress.com Granma International: http://www.granma.cu/ingles/index.html _ table with 2 columns and 6 rows Subj: [bksvol-discuss] Re: Wrote just now to Pavi Date: 11/2/2009 3:43:23 PM Eastern Standard Time From: rhyami@xxxxxxxxx Reply-to: bksvol-discuss@xxxxxxxxxxxxx To: bksvol-discuss@xxxxxxxxxxxxx Sent from the Internet (Details) table end Kim, I think you make people happy by choosing books that make you happy. I know Roger's desire is to be helpful and let you know about the wish list. What he says makes sense. I think our community is so large and diverse that there are bound to be many members who like the things you put into the collection. Yes, we have a large and active wish list. That doesn't mean you necessarily want to read or pay for what someone else is wishing for. By purchasing books you want to read, you are actively taking steps to fill your own wish list requests. You're not adding books to the ever-expanding wish list; you're taking a tangible step toward getting them into the collection. So the net result seems to be the same. (smile) I think my email may sound somewhat stern. I don't intend that and think I should explain why I'm saying these things. The nature of our wish list is that there are some people who have requested over 100 books at a time while being unwilling to help get them into the collection, whether through volunteering to proofread or by providing the books to be scanned. I'm not referring to people who physically can't volunteer or to people who request books and who help with the proofreading. In theory, I do want those hundreds of books to be added to Bookshare, no matter who requested them, because I want everyone to be able to access any book they wish. Still the reality is that the burden of buying, locating, and/or scanning these books falls on our shoulders. This also means that if we spend our time and money on these books, we can't spend our time and money working on books that are important to us. So I feel frustrated when someone says that a volunteer should spend money working on the wish list books instead of buying her own to make people happy. When I get books from Amazon or Paperback Swap, I tend to get 2 books for me and 1 book from the Bookshare wish list. Even then, I primarily use my credits on books I'm willing to read so I can prepare my scan well. I'll take books somewhat outside my interests if the request is clearly for a student or an adult needing a book for their employment. I used to try to be totally fair, doing a book for me and then a book for someone else, whether I liked it or not. I've taken on books in the past that didn't interest me at all, and I found that proofreading them was rather like pulling out my eyelashes strand by strand. I felt drained and burned out pretty quickly. Now I focus on what I do well and trust that others with interests in other areas will do likewise. Sue and Jill taught me to do this, and I am so grateful that they taught me how to keep from overwhelming myself. Monica Willyard "The best way to predict the future is to create it." -- Peter Drucker