[bksvol-discuss] The Princes of Ireland reviews

Gerald, I did it again. I got so carried away writing
my letter I forgot to include the two opposing reviews
of the book.

Just for people's interest, here they are, and they
will explain my comments about doing the book.

The Library Journal says it "sweeps readers through
the early centuries ?" and that the "unfolding of a
colorful and turbulent history is told with energy and
a meticulous attention to historical detail. As he did
so vividly in his previous historical novels (e.g.,
Sarum), Rutherfurd captures the energy, beauty, and
passion that are so much a part of the Irish
experience. He is a marvelous storyteller, and readers
will anticipate the second book. Like James Michener,
Rutherfurd has found the key to crafting sweeping
historical sagas with vitality and flair. Highly
recommended."

Publishers Weekly describes it as a "lackluster saga"
and says "Readers who persevere will glean plenty of
historical detail from these pages, but Rutherfurd's
uninspiring storytelling makes the journey a slog."

CIndy

__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam?  Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around 
http://mail.yahoo.com

Other related posts: