Yes, and so for that reason as well as other reasons that have come up, I can't stress enough that too much is better than not enough. I know the majority of us scanners and validators take pride in submitting most of our material as ready to go as we can make it. Pam >The problem is that anyone who wants to use BookShare for most scholarly >activity is frustrated by the lack of page numbers. >----- Original Message ----- >From: "Mike Pietruk" <pietruk@xxxxxxxxx> >To: <bksvol-discuss@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> >Sent: Saturday, February 05, 2005 10:24 AM >Subject: [bksvol-discuss] Re: Stripper, > > >> One of the big problems, and there is no practical way around it, is books >> are prepared and validated in so many different ways guaranteeing that >> consistency just cannot happen. >> While page numbers, page breaks, and all the rest certainly are desirable >> and should been striven for, >> realistically, if we can get chapter numbers included, we may be achieving >> about all that one can hope for. >> Certainly, the stripper can get part of the blame for the problem, >> certainly book preparation contributes to it, and validators can do only >> so much. >> Hence, the new policy related to page breaks is about all one could have >> hoped for given the nature of the animal we're dealing with. >> I had just submitted a book, Dakota Born by Debbie Macomber, replete with >> page numbers on every page and Chapter numbers protected. >> Fortunately, the Chapter titles were preserved; page numbers are all but >> extinct. >> With this kind of book it doesn't matter, but if the stripper caused this >> problem, even in part, it did a disservice to the membership. >> I suggest again, one is better off with too much rather than not enough >> header and footer junk. >> As long as automated processes are employed by the system and validators >> and submitters to destroy unwanted info, it is inevitable that damage will >> be done. >> And, on the other hand, I don't think painstaking hand edited necessarily >> makes sense either, other than on special books, as that time could be >> better employed elsewhere. >> So, I think we have to learn to live with what the situation is and be >> thankful that the problem even exists as at least we have books we >> otherwise wouldn't have. >> >> >> >