Just my perspective and opinion. I agree with the rule. Just as I was chastised for not reading fast enough to put books in the collection, I feel that having books for months and months on the my checked out books is just as bad. I don't believe that the rule should be changed for "new" volunteers, but if I was a volunteer and could not find a good book to read because everyone had their name on them, I would get discouraged. I do not have a syndicate of friends who scan and can put my name on them. I depend on the checked out books for my books to proof, and when all the mysteries, history, etc. are already being held I end up with the problem I had to deal with a few days ago. Luckily there were a number of people here who came to my rescue, Mary being one, but there still were not enough books. It is a matter of what do you like to read. All the mysteries, etc. are given hold fors and what is left are religious books and technical books I wouldn't know anything or care enough about to proof correctly. If it was a medical transcriptionist book I could proof it, but they are computer books, etc. Everyone should have the same chance of getting books they do not want to particularly proof, not just those who are not hooked up to a scanner. Also, not all volunteers are on this list. It takes time to go through the traffic here so they depend on the checked out list. As for scanning. Good scanners are worth their weight in gold, but, as is my situation, they do not have room enough to make scanning comfortable or perhaps they cannot even afford the necessary equipment to do a great scan. I would have to scan into Word. I do not, nor can I afford, Kurzweil or Open Book. Perhaps this could be a problem for some. Getting books is another problem. Not everyone can search extensively to make certain some publisher has not put the book on Bookshare. Also, getting and paying for books could be a problem. If I can find a way to scan, I am going to do the research necessary. However, not everyone understands enough about computers to do that much research. Just my opinion and perhaps a little thought from the other side of the proverbial coin. Understand I am bucking everyone here, but something needed and should be done about hold fors that just languish. Just as bad in my opinion as renewing and renewing and renewing. Reggie To unsubscribe from this list send a blank Email to bksvol-discuss-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx put the word 'unsubscribe' by itself in the subject line. To get a list of available commands, put the word 'help' by itself in the subject line.