atw: Re: The next question. [Moving on from "Should we always give users what they ask for?"]

Hi Christine,

That's interesting. What you have offered in your first paragraph is the 
definition of 'competency' - not of comprehension.

And then in your second paragraph, you get a bit closer. But you seem to be 
assuming a strong behaviourist stance. I can think of many tasks where we may 
hope for comprehension, but where there may be no observable change in 
behaviour, eg, a change in emotional tone or evaluation.

So, Geoffrey's quest for a means of measuring comprehension or uptake may be 
some way off.

Brian.
  From: Christine Kent 

  Simple - the ability to do the job in a range of real or simulated situations.

   

  "Comprehension" as a word relates only to intellectual awareness.  It is only 
part of any learning story.  Can the person who comprehends DO anything in a 
given situation as a result of that comprehension?  Further, can they 
extrapolate and apply the "comprehension" across a range of new situations.

   

Other related posts: